BBC Radio 2

Guide

There’s something almost sacrilegious about questioning BBC Radio 2’s relevance. For decades, it’s been the soundtrack to British life. It has been the reliable companion that’s guided us through morning commutes, workplace coffee breaks, and also lazy Sunday afternoons. But in 2025, as I watch the latest RAJAR figures roll in showing Heart overtaking Radio 2 as the UK’s most listened-to radio brand for the first time ever, I can’t help but wonder: is this the beginning of the end for the station that once seemed untouchable?

The seismic shift happened quietly, almost apologetically. Radio 2’s audience dropped to 13.1 million listeners in early 2025, while Heart surged to 13.4 million. It’s only a 300,000-listener difference, but symbolically, it’s enormous. Like watching your favorite football team slip from first to second place after years of dominance, it forces you to confront uncomfortable questions about whether the glory days are behind us.

I’ve been listening to Radio 2 for over two decades, from the Chris Evans breakfast show chaos through the Steve Wright afternoon institution, right up to these current uncertain times. What strikes me most isn’t just the numbers, it’s the palpable sense that the station is caught between two worlds, desperately trying to honor its heritage while chasing a younger demographic that increasingly doesn’t listen to linear radio at all.

The great presenter exodus and its consequences (BBC Radio 2)

The most visible symptom of Radio 2’s identity crisis has been the parade of departures that began in earnest in 2023. Ken Bruce’s exit to Greatest Hits Radio was the earthquake that preceded everything else. After 31 years of PopMaster and mid-morning comfort, his departure wasn’t just losing a presenter—it was losing an institution. The numbers don’t lie: Bruce took 1.2 million listeners with him, and his new show now attracts over 4 million weekly listeners. That’s not just audience migration; that’s a damning verdict on Radio 2’s direction.

When Zoe Ball announced her departure from the breakfast show in December 2024, citing the need to “focus on family,” it felt like another domino falling. Ball had steadied the breakfast ship after Chris Evans’s departure, growing the audience from 6.5 million to peaks of 6.8 million. But even success wasn’t enough to keep her in what’s arguably the most demanding job in British radio.

Enter Scott Mills, the 52-year-old former Radio 1 stalwart who’s now tasked with waking up Britain. The appointment divided listeners from day one. Social media lit up with complaints ranging from the predictable (“Radio 2 needs someone with depth and substance”) to the brutal (“his inane chatter drives me to distraction”). But here’s what struck me listening to Mills those first few weeks: he’s genuinely trying to thread an impossible needle, bringing enough energy to appeal to younger listeners while respecting the expectations of an audience that’s 82% over 35.

The presenter changes reflect a deeper strategic challenge. Head of Station Helen Thomas describes the current schedule overhaul as “the biggest change in the network’s history,” but is it evolution or desperation? When I hear DJ Spoony’s expanded presence across four weeknight slots, I appreciate the commitment to musical diversity that Trevor Nelson advocates. Yet I also understand listeners who feel the station is abandoning its roots in pursuit of a demographic that might never fully embrace traditional radio.

The spotify problem and the streaming revolution (BBC Radio 2)

The elephant in every radio executive’s office is streaming. Spotify has 195 million premium subscribers worldwide. Apple Music commands another 100 million. These platforms offer infinite choice, no adverts (for premium users), and algorithms that learn your taste better than any human presenter ever could. So why would anyone choose to surrender control and listen to what someone else picks?

BBC Radio 2’s answer centers on the irreplaceable value of human curation. Jeff Smith, the station’s Head of Music, speaks passionately about Radio 2’s 10,000-song database compared to commercial stations’ typical 500-track rotation. “We’re not a nostalgia station,” he insists, describing Radio 2’s mission as playing “the best music from the past and the best music from today.” It’s a noble vision, but one that requires listeners to trust the curation enough to stick around during songs they don’t immediately recognize.

The station’s “Radio 2 Reimagined” strategy launched in 2019 attempts to walk this tightrope. By reducing 1960s and 70s content while increasing tracks from the 80s, 90s, and 2000s, plus introducing “the new pop establishment” (Dua Lipa, Jess Glynne, Calvin Harris), Radio 2 is trying to sound more contemporary without alienating its core audience. It’s musical diplomacy of the highest order.

But here’s where it gets really interesting: the BBC’s digital strategy suggests they know linear radio alone isn’t enough. BBC Sounds, the corporation’s answer to Spotify, has grown from 760,000 monthly users in 2020 to over 5 million weekly users in 2024. The platform achieved 2.3 billion total plays across all content in 2024. Radio 2’s archive content and exclusive sessions driving significant engagement.

The station’s Piano Room sessions exemplify this hybrid approach perfectly. Watching U2 perform acoustically with the BBC Concert Orchestra, or Stormzy stripping back his hits to their emotional core, provides something no streaming algorithm can replicate: the surprise of discovering familiar songs in entirely new contexts. These sessions, hosted monthly at Maida Vale Studios, have become YouTube phenomena and BBC Sounds favorites, proving that when Radio 2 gets it right, it creates genuinely unmissable content.

The demographics dilemma (BBC Radio 2)

Radio 2’s biggest challenge isn’t Spotify or Heart, it’s actually time itself (A challenge which is hard to come up against). The station’s audience is aging. Furthermore, over 50% of listeners are now over the age of 55. While there’s nothing wrong with serving this demographic, the concern is what happens as younger listeners increasingly default to streaming services for music discovery.

The numbers are sobering: 16-24 year-olds’ usage of Spotify has doubled in recent years, while traditional radio listening in this age group continues declining. Radio 2’s attempts to attract younger listeners, through presenter appointments, social media strategy shifts (quitting Facebook and X to focus on TikTok and Instagram), and contemporary music increases—feel like trying to change course on a supertanker.

Vernon Kay’s mid-morning success offers hope. His show attracts 6.8 million listeners, making it the UK’s most popular radio program. Kay manages to sound both contemporary and comfortable, engaging with current culture while respecting Radio 2’s heritage. When he geeks out about 80s synth-pop one minute and interviews emerging artists the next, it feels natural rather than calculated.

Trevor Nelson’s expanded role also suggests a way forward. His move from the evening Rhythm Nation show to weekday afternoons brings decades of music knowledge and genuine passion to a prime slot. Nelson speaks eloquently about his

“huge responsibility” as a Black presenter on the UK’s biggest station, and his commitment to musical diversity feels authentic rather than tokenistic.

The commercial radio challenge (BBC Radio 2)

The most immediate threat to Radio 2 isn’t digital, it’s terrestrial commercial radio that’s learned from the BBC’s playbook. Heart’s success comes from playing tested hits with minimal presenter chat, giving listeners the comfort of familiarity without the risk of unfamiliar music. It’s the McDonald’s approach to radio: not necessarily the best, but reliably satisfying.

Greatest Hits Radio, meanwhile, has positioned itself as “old Radio 2″—the station that longtime listeners remember before the modernization efforts began. Ken Bruce’s presence legitimizes this positioning, while the playlist focuses squarely on 70s, 80s, and 90s classics without the new music obligations that Radio 2 must fulfill as a public service broadcaster.

This presents Radio 2 with an existential challenge. Commercial stations can focus purely on what audiences want to hear, while Radio 2 must balance entertainment with its remit to introduce new music and support emerging artists. The station is required by Ofcom to play over 20% new music and over 40% UK artists. It is an obligation that commercial competitors don’t face.

The digital-first gamble (BBC Radio 2)

The BBC’s £300 million investment in digital transformation represents the biggest bet on Radio 2’s future. The strategy assumes that while linear radio may decline, the BBC’s content and curation expertise can thrive on digital platforms. BBC Sounds’ growth suggests this isn’t fantasy, the platform now attracts nearly 5 million weekly users and has seen record engagement with music mixes and on-demand content in recent times.

Radio 2’s social media pivot also reflects digital-first thinking. By abandoning Facebook and X to focus resources on TikTok and Instagram, the station acknowledges that its future audience discovery will happen on platforms where music and personality intersect differently. Watching presenter clips get millions of views on TikTok while traditional ratings face pressure suggests this strategy may be prescient.

The challenge is that digital success doesn’t necessarily translate to linear radio success. A brilliant Instagram reel might introduce someone to a Radio 2 presenter, but will they then commit to listening live for three hours on a weekday morning? The attention economy rewards brief, engaging content, while radio’s strength lies in sustained companionship.

International perspectives and the broader context (BBC Radio 2)

Looking beyond the UK, Radio 2’s struggles aren’t unique. Traditional music radio faces similar pressures worldwide as streaming services become the default music consumption method for younger demographics. However, few stations globally attempt Radio 2’s ambitious balance of mass appeal with music discovery obligations.

American public radio serves niche audiences, while commercial stations focus on narrow demographics. European public broadcasters often separate their pop and specialist music services more distinctly. Radio 2’s attempt to be everything to everyone—mainstream but adventurous, contemporary but heritage-aware, accessible but sophisticated—may be uniquely British in its ambition and complexity.

This context makes Radio 2’s current audience figures more impressive than they initially appear. Maintaining 13 million weekly listeners while competing with infinite digital choice and well-funded commercial rivals isn’t failure. It’s an extraordinary achievement that would be impossible without genuine audience loyalty.

The music industry relationship (BBC Radio 2)

One area where Radio 2 maintains clear advantages over streaming platforms is its relationship with the music industry. The station’s influence on careers remains substantial, as evidenced by the Piano Room sessions’ impact on artists from Stormzy to U2. Record labels still view Radio 2 playlisting as crucial for reaching adult audiences and the presenter-artist relationships built over decades create opportunities for exclusive content that streaming platforms can’t replicate.

Jeff Smith’s weekly playlist meetings represent something increasingly rare in the digital age: human music curation at scale. While Spotify’s algorithms excel at recommending similar music, Radio 2’s programming team makes connections between genres, eras, and moods that feel more intuitive and surprising. The station’s ability to place a 1980s classic next to a 2024 debut and make both feel essential is a skill that artificial intelligence hasn’t mastered.

The verdict on relevance (BBC Radio 2)

So is BBC Radio 2 still relevant in 2025? The answer is complicated and depends entirely on what we mean by relevance.

If relevance means market dominance and growing audience numbers, then 2025 has delivered concerning news. Heart’s overtaking of Radio 2 as the UK’s most listened-to radio brand represents a seismic shift that reflects broader changes in media consumption. The presenter departures, audience migration, and demographic challenges are real and significant.

But if relevance means continuing to serve a substantial audience with content they can’t find elsewhere, then Radio 2 remains deeply relevant. Thirteen million weekly listeners represent more people than watch most television programs, attend football matches, or buy music magazines. The station’s combination of live music, trusted curation, and presenter companionship offers something that streaming services struggle to replicate: serendipity and human connection in an increasingly algorithmic world.

The real question isn’t whether Radio 2 is relevant today, but whether it can remain relevant in tomorrow’s world. The digital-first strategy, presenter renewal, and programming evolution suggest the BBC understands the challenges ahead. But, success will require navigating between nostalgia and innovation, serving current listeners while attracting new ones and also maintaining public service obligations while competing for attention in the experience economy.

Listening to Vernon Kay interview a breakthrough artist between classic hits, or hearing Trevor Nelson’s encyclopedic music knowledge illuminate connections between genres, I’m reminded why human curation matters. In an age of infinite choice, sometimes what we need isn’t more options but better guides. Radio 2, at its best, provides exactly that guidance.

The station may no longer be unassailable, but reports of its death are greatly exaggerated. As long as people crave discovery, companionship, and the surprise of hearing something perfect at exactly the right moment, BBC Radio 2 will have a role to play. The question is whether it can play that role compellingly enough to thrive rather than merely survive.

The next few years will provide the answer, but for now, I’m keeping my radio tuned in.

George Millington

Editor at Contact Me

George Millington is a music journalist and reviewer situated in central London. He does not write about a single genre but rather the commercial music industry as a whole. His first album was by The Beatles, which he purchased secondhand from a charity shop in his neighbourhood.

He discovered the gem when he was 12 years old and still has it now, claiming it to be why he fell in love with music. He likes to play disc golf when he's not writing about music. He is a one-of-a-kind individual who is always the first to bust out his air guitar on the dance-floor.

Latest posts by George Millington (see all)

BBC Radio 2 – Is It Still Relevant in 2025 - August 1, 2025
ColdplayGate – The Real Reason It Broke the Internet - July 18, 2025
Oasis Reunion 2025: Was It Worth The Wait? - July 7, 2025